Skip to main content

One post tagged with "Luffy's scar"

View All Tags

· 7 min read
Taig Mac Carthy

You don't know what you would be able to achieve if you were willing to really sacrifice yourself to achieve it. We don't know what would happen, because normal people don't usually don't tend to sacrifice themselves. We are not willing to sacrify to fulfill our dreams.

But in One Piece we are watching precisely this play out. We are seeing a person who is willing to sacrify himself to alarming lenghts. Luffy is a young boy, an orphan, who is willing to sacrify his wellbeing, his life, to achieve a magnificent goal. And we see him transform in the process, and we see him progress towards this goal as a consequence.

It is very easy to remember times in which Luffy put his life in danger to achieve his goal, to defeat an enemy or to protect a friend. We have seen Luffy bleed and sustain deadly injuries so often that it does not surprise us anymore. But you may have not noticed that his willingness to sacrify himself is present from the earliest point of the story.

ArtDialogue
  • I've had it with you guys!! Now You'll have to take me seriously. This is how tough I am!!!
  • Ha ha ha! Get it over with! Whatever it is...
  • What is that kid up to now?

When Luffy was a small child, he wanted Shanks to take him with him in his adventures. But Shanks refused, claiming that Luffy was still a child, who was afraid of being harmed, looked cute and drank milk – typically childish things. Luffy knew that his childliness was in the way of his goal. So, in a weirdly ritualistic act, he cut his own face with a knife.

When I say ritualistic I really mean it. He clibs to the top of the mast of the ship, which is the leading section of the ship, quite literally, and also a high spot from where he can be seen by everyone. And right there, gets a knife out, and inject it into his face.

This seems barbaric. Everyone seems to think so, even these tough pirates are apalled. And you may look at it and think that it is stupid, barbaric or dumb. But it's not.

If you look back in history, most cultures had some form or other of ritualistic sacrifice. You see this in the Bible, as early as Abraham. Abraham was constanly making sacrifices. Before embarking on a journey or doing something important, he would grab a baby lamb or something valuable, and he would sacrifice it. This may seem, again: barbaric, primitive and supersticious. But think about it. Even if you think about it as a modern person, you have to admit that the act of sacrificing something may have some dramatic effect on your own mind. Imagine yourself going to a field, grabbing a newborn lamb, and cutting its throat. And think that in the times of Abraham a lamb was something very valuable, so instead of eating it, he would burn it. It would be like buying an iPhone in today's world, and burning it. It is a way of indicating to yourself that you are serious about something. I don't really have another example. Which shows that nowadays we don't seem to have rituals of seriousness.

Imagine that you are serious about a goal. For instance, you want to get into shape, because you are unhappy with your fat ass. And you sign up at a gym. Okay, now imagine that you also grab a baby lamb, kill it with your own blody hands, and burn an iPad in a fire, as a token of your commitment. Imagine that. Are you willing to do that? I don't think so. So maybe you are not serious enough about getting in shape. So it's not so obvious that we are actually serious about anything. But imagine if you did slay the lamb: wouldn't the memory of killing the lamb stick with you and remind you about your commitment? I think it would. So maybe Abraham and all those people were not stupid and primitive. Maybe they knew something that we don't. And so did Luffy when he was 6 years old.

Is Luffy commited to his dream of becoming the king of pirates? You bet you ass he is. How do you know? Because he sacrifices himself over and over again to fulfill it. His commitment is derived from his sacrifice. They are the same thing. Indeed, the story of One Piece one of sacrifice in pursue of one's dreams. And this is true from the very begining, when Luffy is 6 years old and put a knife in his cute little face.

And I think that it is truly beautiful that in One Piece the ideas of sacrifice and commitment are embeded into the narrative, at the level of dramatic action. Instead of abstract explanations, Luffy is acting out the idea of sacrifice and commitment, from the very begining of the story. And it looks simple, but the fundamental concepcion is so profound. And it's truly breathtaking when you understand what message is trying to be conveyed.

You cannot be sure of your commitment without sacrifice. Well, actually, achieving a great goal almost always requires self sacrifice. And what do you have to sacrifice to achieve a great goal? That which is currently stopping you from achieving your goals. And specially the things that difficult to sacrify. In Luffy's case, his child-like attibutes: his fear of getting harm, his child-like cuteness; which are valuable things, that are getting in the way. And by sacrificing these valuable things, he transcends them, willinglly, empowering his commitment, which in turn empowers him.

So, am I advising 6 year old kids to take a knife and injure their faces? Well, maybe not. Depends on why they would do it. But what I'm saying, and what Luffy represents, is that if you are going to embark on an adventure to fulwill your dream, you are going to undergo some radical transformations. You will have to change things about yourself. And transforming yourself is a form of self harm. Psychologically speaking, you kill a part of yourself. You kill the part of yourself that is stopping you from fulfilling your dream.

So self-transformation is always sacrificial. You are voluntaryly sacrificing a part of yourself. So the call to fulfilling your dream is also the call to a series of deaths and rebirths, that move you closer and closer to your goal. And that is what the One Piece is calling Luffy to do, right in the first volume of the story. Showing you that Luffy is all about commitment, and zero about excuses.

And I think that it also becomes obvious, through Luffy, that the willingness to sacrifice oneself does not mean, at all, having suicidal tendencies. Luffy is clearly not depressed. If anything, it's the opposite. And this is a weird phenomena, right? If I didn't have the example of Luffy, it would be difficult for me to explain the difference between suicidal tendencies, versus willingness to sacrifice oneself.

But when you look at Luffy, you see very clearly what is happening. He is so full of will to live, he is so commited to his goal, that he is willing to sustain harm. He wants to live so much, that he is willing to kill certain parts of himself. This is nothing, absolutely nothing to do with people who are depresses and are willing to kill themselves.

Or maybe it does? Now that I think about it. Maybe in a certain way, altough I don't think this is the case. Think about this: imagine if you are not able to diferentiate the parts of you that are holding you down. You don't know what you should sacrify. You don't have the clarity to diagnose your own problem, or maybe you don't have clarity about your goals and your dreams. And without the clarity, without knowing what you want to do, a which parts of you are holding you down, maybe killing the whole thing may be a possible answer. But I really don't think that this is what happens in the mind of most people who consider killing themselves, but maybe it does.